Skip to content
Meet our Integrity professionals at the Banff Pipeline Workshop, 12–15 April 2027 See the event →
ACiD Integrity Inc.
Search Request a quote
ACiD Integrity Inc.
Search Quote
HomeCase studiesWhy a reclaimed-water fitting failed, and what the standard should say

CASE STUDY 10 · ALBERTA · MUNICIPAL WATER

Why a reclaimed-water fitting failed, and what the standard should say

A root-cause review of a corrosion failure on a 15.3 km reclaimed-water line, and the changes to the owner's standards and CP specification that stop the next one.

Municipal water utility · via its engineering consultant

  • Cathodic Protection
  • Failure analysis
  • Specification review
15.3 km
Reclaimed-water line reviewed
2 of 55
Soil test sites not corrosive in any category
~100×
Sulphide at the failure sites, against the owner's limit
5
Dig locations recommended

The problem

On a reclaimed-water line of mostly 500 mm PVC pipe with ductile iron valves and fittings, the carbon steel retaining bolts on a ductile iron tee corroded through. A test dig 100 m away found another fitting close to failure. The owner needed the root cause, and changes to its standards to prevent more failures on this line and on similar systems.

Schematic of a 15.3 km reclaimed-water line: 55 soil test sites, 2 of them not corrosive in any category; the failed tee and the near-failure fitting 100 m away; five recommended digs; sulphide at the failure sites about 100 times the limit.

What we did

  1. 01
    Gather the evidence
    As-built drawings, post-failure photos, a third-party metallurgical analysis of the second fitting and third-party soil data from 55 test holes along the right of way were reviewed.
  2. 02
    Benchmark the criteria
    The owner's soil-corrosivity limits were compared with ASTM, AWWA, DIN EN 12501 and Caltrans limits, and the new soil results with the pre-construction testing.
  3. 03
    Check what was built
    Materials, coatings and CP were checked against the specifications. The bolts were carbon steel where the specification called for stainless steel.
  4. 04
    Look for MIC
    Microbiologically influenced corrosion indicators and the effect of polyethylene encasement on CP were assessed, with sample zinc versus magnesium anode calculations.
  5. 05
    Fix the standard, plan the line
    Recommendations for the owner's standards (CP by or under an AMPP CP2 technician, magnesium anodes and surveyable CP where soils exceed the limits, no polyethylene encasement with CP) and for the line itself, including a dig programme.

Have a similar asset?

Tell us about the main, line or structure. An engineer reads every request, and anything that needs a stamp goes to one of our Professional Engineers.

Have an asset that needs protecting?
Request a quote
AMPP CP Level 4ISNetworldAvettaComplyWorks